Re-evaluating the grading of quarters
DEAR SIR,
�@�@Three blocks
of flats at Telford Garden which have been police married
quarters since early 1980 are graded either G or H. But the grading has not been
re-evaluated for years. I think it should be, especially in light of the newly completed
Wong Tai Sin quarters.
�@In the past, Telford Garden's quality in comparison to other quarters attracted many
high-score officers who were willing to pay more to live there in line with the better
living standards the estate offered.
�@However, it is understood that quarters at Wong Tai Sin now enjoy better treatment
in classification than Telford Garden. This makes me wonder why my G-graded flat
in Telford Gardens of 50.8 sq/m is taking $1,742.5 from my salary while a 58.9 sq/m
H-graded in Wong Tai Sin costs just $929? Am I over-paying?
�@I urge the Force to review the matter as soon as possible.
�@Furthermore, under existing policy police officers are entitled to apply for married
quarters once they become eligible - that is, they get married. May I suggest that police
officers who marry fellow police officers should be graded higher than officers who
marry non-Force members since the Force will ultimately save one quarter under
such a situation.
�@I do hope that Management will look into the above matters and improve the system.
Yours sincerely
Team 7 CAPO HKI
(Name Provided)
Cheung Kam-chuen, SP Quarters, replies . . .
DEAR SIR,
�@�@Grading of
departmental quarters is determined by a number of factors
that include, among other things, size, location, view and facilities. Any single factor
such as the size should not be pitched too high because when compared with government
built quarters, flats in private developments are usually more convenient with better
facilities.
�@The grading process involves professional judgements and is undertaken by the
Government Property Administrator (GPA), not the Police Force. To ensure that grading
can appropriately reflect the standard of quarters, regular review is conducted by GPA.
�@Though the rent ceiling of G-grade quarters is higher than that of H-grade, the occupant
of G-grade quarters will be eligible for additional benefits which are only available to
quarters of G-grade or above.
�@Examples are: Quarters may be decorated in the colour of the officer's choice; Provision of
government standard furniture at an enhanced scale; Provision of electrical appliances.
�@As regards to the suggestion of granting additional quartering points to married police
couples, I wish to point out that it is Government policy for a married couple not to receive
concurrent housing benefits. If the respective quartering points of a married police couple
can either wholly or partially be combined, they may acquire quarters of better quality and
standard in competition with other applicants whose spouses are not police officers.
�@It is worth mentioning that the number of married couples who are both police officers is
far less than those who are not. As this issue has Force-wide implications, it will be passed
to the Staff Associations for comments and considered by the Quarters Allocation Committee.
|